Facebook Messenger Campaign Cage Match


Link Clicks VS Messenger Reply, Which Should I Optimize For?

If you’re reading this, we’re going to assume two things:  

  1. You know what a Facebook Messenger campaign is
  2. You want to get the best result for your ad dollars on Facebook

Ok, with that out of the way, we don’t need to spend time talking about the magnitude of Facebook Messenger and why we believe that it will become THE SINGLE LARGEST CHANNEL for digital marketers.

So, which type of Campaign Objective should you tell Facebook to optimize for in order to get the best results from your Messenger campaigns?

Well…What Are My Options?

As far as Facebook is concerned, when you set up a Messenger campaign there’s only one option, optimizing for Messenger replies.

When selecting the Messages campaign objective, Facebook will show your ad to users it believes are most likely to click through into a Messenger conversation.

Sounds perfect, right?  You’re trying to get people into a Messenger conversation and so is Facebook.  Match made in heaven!

Not so fast. There’s a small issue that got us thinking.  As it turns out, if you choose the Messages campaign objective, Facebook will only show your ads to users who have the Messenger app installed on their mobile devices!

This might not be a problem for some brands, however others might want to target a population that hasn’t downloaded and installed Messenger at as high of a high rate, making this a concern for marketers looking to optimize on Messenger.

The Alternative? Trusty Traffic Campaigns

If you believe a large percentage of your customers might not have the Messenger app downloaded, you can run a traditional Traffic campaign.  The trick here is to create a REF link in your bot building platform to use as the destination URL in your Facebook ad. (How to: ManyChat | Chatfuel )

With the help of a link shortener like Bit.ly or TinyURL, you can use your new REF link to send users directly from your Facebook ad into a Messenger conversation!

Which Should I Choose?

While we can’t really tell you which type of campaign will be the best for your brand, we can however encourage you to test the two campaign types and pick a winner.

In Facebook you’ll want to create two campaigns, one with the campaign objective set to Messenger, and another set to Traffic.  Be sure to keep your audiences and ads as similar as possible in these two campaigns with the exception of the destination of the ad.  

How We Measured Results

To find out which type of campaign works best we measure cost per Messenger subscriber.  Getting this number is not as hard as is might seem. The cost part is easy, simply set the date range in Facebook Ads Manager for the dates of your test and record the cost of each campaign.

To get the number of subscribers, you’ll need to dive into your messenger platform.  In our case, we used Chatfuel, so we’ll show screenshots from that platform, but most major chatbot platforms will be similar.

By looking in the Sources section of Chatfuel Analytics we are able to see how many Interactions and New Users were driven from each source.  We’re interested in New Users, as these are people who are now reachable by future broadcast messages.

With this data it’s as easy dividing the total campaign cost by the number of New Users acquired.  

Our Results

To test this out we turned to a large eCommerce client who has been using Facebook ads to grow their Messenger subscriber list.  For this specific business, we were able to acquire Messenger subscribers for $1.97 using a Messenger campaign objective versus $1.54 per subscriber when using a Traffic campaign.

While this might seem like a subtle difference, it will save the business over $2,000 by the time they reach 5,000 subscribers. That’s a cost savings of 40%!!!

Want More?

Follow us on Messenger. We’ll show you how to 10x sales and revenue using the same tactics and strategies we use to scale growth for dozens of eCommerce brands.

Share on email
Share on facebook
Share on linkedin
Share on twitter
Share on reddit



Get ready to discuss fresh ideas and proven strategies unlike any you've ever tried. We're often able to lower CPA while doubling, even tripling your sales...while continually scaling results within just a few short months.